Estimated reading time: 1 minute
With the Picture-by-Picture (PbP) format, Twitch now automatically mutes the stream’s audio whenever an ad begins. The main video continues to play in a smaller window above the chat, but without sound. This change is part of Twitch’s new ad experience rollout, which aims to allow uninterrupted visual content while advertising runs. However, once the ad ends, Twitch does not automatically restore the stream audio. Viewers are left with a muted stream and have to manually unmute it to resume listening. This adds friction to the experience and can result in viewers missing key parts of the stream if they don’t realize the sound is off. The platform has not communicated this behavior clearly in advance, and some users initially believed it to be a bug rather than an intentional feature. ➤ (Source: GameRant)
Viewer Reactions and Workarounds
Viewer reactions to the PbP ad implementation have been largely negative, especially due to the persistent mute after ads. Many users feel this is a poor user experience, particularly when they return to a stream and find it unexpectedly silent. On social platforms and Twitch-related forums, users have raised concerns that Twitch is prioritizing advertiser needs over viewer convenience.
As a result, some have turned to browser-level solutions to restore functionality. Scripts and extensions on platforms like Greasy Fork detect when an ad starts and ends. They actively mute the stream during the ad and unmute it once the ad finishes. These tools help viewers bring back the seamless experience they had before Twitch introduced the PbP system. However, relying on third-party scripts presents limitations. Not all users are comfortable installing custom code in their browser, and these tools may break if Twitch updates its platform or ad logic.
Impact on Twitch Streamers
Streamers have voiced concerns over how the change affects their audiences. Because viewers may not realize their stream is muted after an ad, engagement can suffer. Important conversations, game-changing moments, or key instructions may be missed. This can lead to repeated questions in chat or confusion during live broadcasts.
Some creators have noted a visible drop in interaction during and shortly after ad breaks. This undermines the continuity of the stream, especially in community-driven or narrative-heavy broadcasts. For smaller streamers trying to build an audience, even minor disruptions to viewer flow can have a long-term impact. They also lack control over the ad mechanics, as the muting behavior is imposed by the platform and cannot be toggled off. ➤ (Source: GameRant)
Twitch Rationale
Twitch has not published an official, in-depth explanation for why the stream remains muted after ads conclude. The only formal communication is the feature page on the Twitch Help site, which explains the PbP ad design but does not justify the persistent mute. One plausible reason is that Twitch wants viewers to focus fully on the ad, both visually and aurally, increasing the effectiveness of impressions and boosting advertiser satisfaction.
However, by not restoring audio automatically, Twitch is placing the burden on users to restore their experience. The lack of transparency about this choice has left streamers and viewers guessing about the platform’s intentions, fueling further criticism in the community.
Community Feedback and Future Developments
Feedback from both viewers and streamers continues to accumulate. The Twitch community has raised the issue across platforms like Reddit, Twitter, and Discord. Some request a toggle to allow automatic unmute after ads, while others call for the option to opt out of PbP entirely. Despite the growing concerns, Twitch has not yet indicated any plans to adjust the feature or roll out new options. ➤ (Source: GameRant)
The silence from Twitch has led to speculation about whether the PbP system will remain unchanged or see future revisions. Until then, users are left with makeshift workarounds and platform limitations. Streamers continue to adapt, occasionally adding audio cues or visual reminders in their overlays to warn viewers about the mute behavior post-ad. Whether this becomes standard practice or Twitch revisits the design remains to be seen. For more reviews and news, stay tuned to our website.
